Pheilie entered the game as a newbie, she threw certain competitions to make her look less of a threat in the beginning whilst strategically placing herself in the middle of the house so that noone saw her as a threat. On week 2 Pheilie joined an all girls alliance that was dead-set on removing the threats from the house. On the first half of the double eviction on week 5, Pheilie proved her loyalty by winning the POV competition and saving Morgan even when she was still on the block. After she was nominated the first time she was out for blood winning both the HOH and the POV on the second half of the double and managing to evict Jenny who was a major threat socially. After she showed her skills in competitions she was the "other sides" main target and managed to be vetoed twice in a row by her allies. With the odds stacked against her she managed to win the triple eviction HOH on the second half of week 8 sending out major threats Biel and Axel whilst weakening their alliance massively. It wasn't until week 9 that she lost the POV due to it being a luck competition and was sent out in a 1-1 tie and Micko evicted her seeing her as the best gameplayer this season and major threat to win.
Pheilie later returned for BB10 for a second shot as America voted her back in. During week 1, Pheilie and her BFF, Idolite, were targeted immediately by Aidan. However, won the BOTB and dethroned him. She remained safe during week 2, and was able to win a roadkill competition in week 3, nominating Aidan and being the reason he was evicted. She won HOH during part 1 of week 5, however was dethroned. She laid low for quite some time and won the POV during week 7, saving herself. Her game came crashing down during week 8, the instant eviction. Herself and her ally, Idolite, were nominated and ultimately didn't survive together. Idolite was evicted 4-1-0 but Pheilie decided to walk as she wasn't happy with what went down. She did not cast a jury vote and placed 8th. She sorta didn't improve this time around. Having Idolite and her friends gave her an advantage, and she was the sole reason her game came to an end as she walked.